FFASTrans - FranceBB & Algie Custom Workflows

Questions and answers on how to get the most out of FFAStrans
User avatar
FranceBB
Posts: 231
Joined: Sat Jun 25, 2016 3:43 pm
Contact:

Re: FFASTrans - FranceBB & Algie Custom Workflows

Post by FranceBB »

Well, on ffmpeg I would use something like -c:a pcm_s24le -ar 48000 -af loudnorm=I=-24:LRA=8:tp=-2 however I'm using the default XDCAM block and I didn't want to write a custom ffmpeg block as I wanted to make use of the logic built inside the XDCAM Node made by Steinar, so I kinda had to implement it via Avisynth. Please note that I made it way before the option of doing a loudness correction was introduced inside FFASTrans. Now, in Avisynth, you can do some pretty basic adjustments like Amplify(1.25) or Amplify(0.85) and so on to increase or decrease the volume by a rate factor or AmplidyDB() to increase or decrease it by specifying a value in dB, however this is not what I wanted of course. What I used instead is Normalize() which detects the peak of the audio and performs loudness correction accordingly. Now, one of the things that it's not gonna do is raise the volume, in other words, if it's too high it's gonna lower it down, but if it's too low it won't bring it up, so it's not a totally perfect loudness correction in that sense, however it's generally good enough for general purpose contents that are used for sports events and news. As to movies and other things, they go through the Dolby DP600 instead that performs a real proper loudness correction.
Lastly for -23LUFS you can try with Normalize(0.21) that should do the work. If it's still too low try with (0.20) but it should be fine. Anyway, the ffmpeg one with the audio filter "loudnorm" is more precise than the Avisynth one.
momocampo
Posts: 592
Joined: Thu Jun 08, 2017 12:36 pm
Location: France-Paris

Re: FFASTrans - FranceBB & Algie Custom Workflows

Post by momocampo »

Hello.
That's a perfect explanation, thanks a lot. Ok so it's more a "audio limiter" than a loudness correction but you're right, the most important is to avoid too loud sound.
Thanks for -23 lufs, I will try that.
Cheers.

B.
Koati
Posts: 9
Joined: Tue Jun 06, 2017 7:05 am
Location: Kirkkonummi-Finland

Re: FFASTrans - FranceBB & Algie Custom Workflows

Post by Koati »

Thank you so much for sharing these!
Post Reply